The average person receives more than 120 emails daily, so creating a newsletter that cuts through the noise and genuinely engages readers is both an art and a science. The difference between newsletters that get opened, read, and acted upon versus those that land straight in the trash often comes down to a few key principles.
Start with purpose, not promotion
The most engaging newsletters begin with a clear understanding of why they exist beyond selling products or services. Great newsletters solve problems, provide valuable insights, or offer entertainment that readers genuinely want to receive. Before crafting your first issue, ask yourself: What unique value can I provide that my audience can’t easily find elsewhere?
For example: Morning Brew’s success in making business news accessible and entertaining.
The Hustle transforms dry entrepreneurship content into engaging stories.
The AI Rundown delivers bite-sized updates and ideas on emerging AI.
These publications succeed because they prioritise reader value over self-promotion, building trust that translates into long-term engagement.
Master the art of the subject line
Effective subject lines create curiosity, hint at the value inside, and maintain consistency with your brand voice. They’re specific enough to set expectations, but intriguing enough to encourage opens. Ted Nicholas used to say that you should spend 80% of your writing time on the headline – and a subject line is just that.
Avoid overused phrases like ‘Don’t miss out’ or lots of exclamation marks that trigger spam filters. Instead, ask questions, use numbers or interesting facts, or create a sense of exclusivity. Test different approaches with small segments of your audience to discover what resonates best with your readership.
Design for scanners, not readers
Most newsletter readers don’t read—they scan. Design your content with clear hierarchies using headers, subheaders, bullet points, and white space to guide the eye naturally down the page.
Add relevant images, dividers, or highlight quotes to create visual breathing room.
Keep paragraphs short, typically no more than three sentences, and use formatting like bold text or italics strategically to highlight key points. If the reader just reads the headlines, subheads and bold words, will they get your message?
Consistency builds anticipation
Successful newsletters establish and maintain consistent publishing schedules, whether daily, weekly, or monthly. Consistency isn’t just about timing—it extends to tone, format, and quality. Readers should know what to expect when they see your newsletter in their inbox.
This doesn’t mean every issue needs to be identical, but there should be recognisable elements that create familiarity. Perhaps you always start with a personal note, include this month’s ‘aha moment’ section, or end with a thought-provoking question or observation.
Personalisation goes beyond names
While including a subscriber’s name in the greeting is a start, true personalisation goes much deeper. Use data about subscriber behaviour, preferences, and engagement history to tailor content relevance. This might mean segmenting your list based on interests, past purchases, or engagement levels.
Consider allowing subscribers to choose their own adventure by selecting topics they’re most interested in or letting them control frequency preferences. The goal is making each reader feel like the newsletter was crafted specifically for them, not just sent to a mass list.
Tell stories, don’t just share information
Information is abundant and forgettable; stories are memorable and shareable. Even in business or industry newsletters, weaving narrative elements into your content makes it more engaging. Share case studies as stories, use customer examples, or relate industry trends to real-world scenarios that readers can visualise.
Stories create emotional connections that pure information cannot. Readers remember your content and are more likely to forward it to colleagues or friends.
Create genuine two-way communication
The best newsletters feel like conversations, not broadcasts. Encourage replies by asking questions, seeking feedback, or inviting readers to share their own experiences. When readers do respond, actually engage with them. Reply to emails, feature reader questions or stories, and acknowledge your community in meaningful ways.
Value quality over quantity
Resist the urge to include everything interesting you’ve found in a single issue. Curate ruthlessly, focusing on a few high-quality pieces of content rather than overwhelming readers with options. It’s better to provide deep insight on two topics than surface-level coverage of ten.
Quality also extends to your writing. Take time to edit, ensure accuracy, and maintain your unique voice. Readers can sense when content has been hastily thrown together.
*****
Creating an engaging newsletter requires balancing creativity and data. By focusing on genuine value creation and respecting your readers’ time, you can build a newsletter that not only gets opened, but genuinely impacts your audience.
